Is there any satire in this film?

[klute]

Like in the comics?

I'm not sure i'd want to see satire in the film personally........BUTTTTTTTT as long as the damn film is released,i get to see it,it's arsom then i could care less about the satire

I am a self respecting



Why any self respecting Dredd fan wouldn't want to see some satire in the film is beyond me.    It'll just be a straight action film otherwise.

I am a self respecting  Dredd fan and no i'm not interested in satire there was enough of that with Stallone's pile of shite if i wanted satire i'd what american pie 50 or whatever it is that's currently doing the round's.

[ABCwarBOT]

Like in the comics?

I'm not sure i'd want to see satire in the film personally........BUTTTTTTTT as long as the damn film is released,i get to see it,it's arsom then i could care less about the satire

I am a self respecting



Why any self respecting Dredd fan wouldn't want to see some satire in the film is beyond me.    It'll just be a straight action film otherwise.

I am a self respecting  Dredd fan and no i'm not interested in satire there was enough of that with Stallone's pile of shite if i wanted satire i'd what american pie 50 or whatever it is that's currently doing the round's.

Was there?   I can't remember much satire in Stallones film.   I haven't seen it for years so if there is any please remind me.

So you just want a straightforward action flick then....even though satire's been a big part of Dredd from the beginning?

[Bubba Zebill]

[/quote]

I am a self respecting  Dredd fan and no i'm not interested in satire there was enough of that with Stallone's pile of shite if i wanted satire i'd what american pie 50 or whatever it is that's currently doing the round's.
[/quote]

Was there?   I can't remember much satire in Stallones film.   I haven't seen it for years so if there is any please remind me.

So you just want a straightforward action flick then....even though satire's been a big part of Dredd from the beginning?
[/quote]

That was shat-ire not satire.

[Hoagy]

Wow. Am I in the wrong here? JUst seems that anyone liking the film is a dissenting voice to you and the nitpickers and are dismissed as fanboys and idiots. I know this is a boring threadjacking post but I just had voice me only now near repaired feelings about the the subject. Just because I like what I like about it I get dismissed as a rosy spectacled flibbedyjibbet who can't say yay about anything. I thought this was the nicest place on the web but obviously I'm not a real fan.

[klute]

Like in the comics?

I'm not sure i'd want to see satire in the film personally........BUTTTTTTTT as long as the damn film is released,i get to see it,it's arsom then i could care less about the satire

I am a self respecting



Why any self respecting Dredd fan wouldn't want to see some satire in the film is beyond me.    It'll just be a straight action film otherwise.

I am a self respecting  Dredd fan and no i'm not interested in satire there was enough of that with Stallone's pile of shite if i wanted satire i'd what american pie 50 or whatever it is that's currently doing the round's.

Was there?   I can't remember much satire in Stallones film.   I haven't seen it for years so if there is any please remind me.

So you just want a straightforward action flick then....even though satire's been a big part of Dredd from the beginning?

Yeah i do want a straightforward action film.I'd rather they missed out the satire.Stallone's Judge Dredd was horrid and the less said about Rob Schneider the better.

Was there?   I can't remember much satire in Stallones film.

Oh yeah there was a bucket load it's hard to miss.

[Frank]

Satire isn't the same thing as comedy.

[klute]

Satire isn't the same thing as comedy.

Indeed......some one should have told danny cannon that.

[Misanthrope]

The very nature of Dredd is satire. He was created as a backlash to Thatcherite Britain.

[klute]

The very nature of Dredd is satire. He was created as a backlash to Thatcherite Britain.

Indeed i just feel personally FOR ME i'd prefer the less is more approach to satire

[ABCwarBOT]

Like in the comics?

I'm not sure i'd want to see satire in the film personally........BUTTTTTTTT as long as the damn film is released,i get to see it,it's arsom then i could care less about the satire

I am a self respecting



Why any self respecting Dredd fan wouldn't want to see some satire in the film is beyond me.    It'll just be a straight action film otherwise.

I am a self respecting  Dredd fan and no i'm not interested in satire there was enough of that with Stallone's pile of shite if i wanted satire i'd what american pie 50 or whatever it is that's currently doing the round's.

Was there?   I can't remember much satire in Stallones film.   I haven't seen it for years so if there is any please remind me.

So you just want a straightforward action flick then....even though satire's been a big part of Dredd from the beginning?

Yeah i do want a straightforward action film.I'd rather they missed out the satire.Stallone's Judge Dredd was horrid and the less said about Rob Schneider the better.

Was there?   I can't remember much satire in Stallones film.

Oh yeah there was a bucket load it's hard to miss.

Where's this satire in the Stallone film then?    Please refresh me as I haven't seen it for a long time and I can't really remember there being any.

[klute]

Like in the comics?

I'm not sure i'd want to see satire in the film personally........BUTTTTTTTT as long as the damn film is released,i get to see it,it's arsom then i could care less about the satire

I am a self respecting



Why any self respecting Dredd fan wouldn't want to see some satire in the film is beyond me.    It'll just be a straight action film otherwise.

I am a self respecting  Dredd fan and no i'm not interested in satire there was enough of that with Stallone's pile of shite if i wanted satire i'd what american pie 50 or whatever it is that's currently doing the round's.

Was there?   I can't remember much satire in Stallones film.   I haven't seen it for years so if there is any please remind me.

So you just want a straightforward action flick then....even though satire's been a big part of Dredd from the beginning?

Yeah i do want a straightforward action film.I'd rather they missed out the satire.Stallone's Judge Dredd was horrid and the less said about Rob Schneider the better.

Was there?   I can't remember much satire in Stallones film.

Oh yeah there was a bucket load it's hard to miss.

Where's this satire in the Stallone film then?    Please refresh me as I haven't seen it for a long time and I can't really remember there being any.

Is this a wind up??

[Frank]

The very nature of Dredd is satire. He was created as a backlash to Thatcherite Britain

Thatcher wasn't elected until 1979. Precognition is not one of Wagner's many talents.

[Definitely Not Mister Pops]

I've just checked IMDB and there's no such actor called Any Satire

[Misanthrope]

The very nature of Dredd is satire. He was created as a backlash to Thatcherite Britain

Thatcher wasn't elected until 1979. Precognition is not one of Wagner's many talents.

I beg to differ.

[Hoagy]

I've just checked IMDB and there's no such actor called Any Satire

Have you tried N. E. Satire?