I entirely understad your opinions, PJ, which are put in your usual reasonable and well-written way. I also understand your feelings - it must be very gutting to put weeks of your life into something and just get a 'that sucks' response from someone.
I'm not a creator, but I can't think of any rules that would make the board less hurtful for creators. If I were a creator, I would either avoid the board, or just steel myself everytime I looked at it. Would a beautifully written review that took someone ten minutes of great care to write, but which meant pretty much the same as 'this story is the worst ever published' be less painful to read than 'meh'?
I was saddened by Matt's original post because, with a few exceptions, I like the free feel of this site
no problem using my real name of course,
Floyd Kermode
I'm not a creator, but I can't think of any rules that would make the board less hurtful for creators. If I were a creator, I would either avoid the board, or just steel myself everytime I looked at it. Would a beautifully written review that took someone ten minutes of great care to write, but which meant pretty much the same as 'this story is the worst ever published' be less painful to read than 'meh'?
I was saddened by Matt's original post because, with a few exceptions, I like the free feel of this site
no problem using my real name of course,
Floyd Kermode