Main Menu

FFT - What if? Tie 3 - Red Seas vs Stickleback

Started by Colin YNWA, 20 September, 2022, 06:21:20 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Colin YNWA

A day to go and its a little quieter on this one than I expected - though folks have every right to be burnt out. Anyway a day to rally the votes and make the call and I'll count up in the morning.

Blue Cactus

D'israeli is just incredible but story-wise I'm voting Red Seas.

paddykafka


sintec


maryanddavid


IndigoPrime

I like Stickleback a lot, but I'd rather re-read Red Seas. Just.

Colin YNWA

VOTING CLOSED

A little surprised by this one. Red Seas seemed to get a tarnished rep as it headed towards its end, it seemed like folks had had enough. I wonder wherever the recent collection in the UC has given some folks the chance to reevaluate. Or maybe, like me folks have also loved the Harryhausen pirate epic? Stickleback isn't without its own controversies and possibly more damaging long hiatus. Still I thought it was more popular and while this was close

Red Seas

floats to the surface and sends Stickleback down to Dave Jone's locker.