Forums Favourite Thrill - Scarlet Apocrypha vs Judge Death - Round 1 Heat 3

[Rogue Judge]

De'ath Young Death is a great story, loves the art too.

[Southstreeter]

JD

[Dark Jimbo]

De'ath Young Death is a great story, loves the art too.

Young Death doesn't count here, that'll be a separate vote later.

[Rogue Judge]

De'ath Young Death is a great story, loves the art too.

Young Death doesn't count here, that'll be a separate vote later.

Ah gotcha, guess I should read the description more closely! Just Judge Death then, I've read a handful of JD one-offs and have enjoyed them.

[Funt Solo]

So, my Judge Death data suggests this is mostly My Name is Death plus The Wilderness Days - some Wagner and Irving goodness from the the noughties.

Countering that is some Durham Red alternity dipping from the Dabnett droid that I'm not sure even belongs under its own banner.

My vote goes to Judge Death.

[The Enigmatic Dr X]

Cheat's game!

Death

[Blue Cactus]

Judge Death.

[repoman]

Judge Death, obviously.

[I, Cosh]

Scarlet Apocrypha I've never read.

Judge Death wins by default.

[Link Prime]

The Scarlet Apocrypha was great fun, and the winner for me.

[Colin YNWA]

Just today folks, just today. I'll count up in the morning so get ya votes in today.

[paddykafka]

Judge Death

[O Lucky Stevie!]

A series of continual reimaginings versus a charismatic one-note character?

I choose Scarlet Apocrypha.

[Colin YNWA]

VOTING CLOSED

It all pretty clear here and while the variety of votes, which so delights me, abounds its our clearest victory to date and

Judge Death

Will err, well, live again in the 2nd round. Scarlet Apocrypha might be out, but Durham Red will come back and we'll see how she does there...