Why isn't The Rocketeer universially loved? Its almost impossible not imagine not falling for its easy charms...
...and maybe there lies the problem. I'd not seen it for an age. In fact possibly since not in the day, since it came out (on video) at least. I've seen bits of it loads of times, but never sat down since then to watch it all. I've always cast it aside thinking it was pretty dull. I've loved the comics for years and seeing as a new comic series had started and this was on Disney+ I thought why not give it another go, not expecting much... and loved it, absolutely loved it.
The only problem is that easy charm, its a little too easy, its not dull, far, from it but the direction could be tighter. The action could be a bit slicker. I mean a Nazi, Mob, FBI shot out and it doesn't quite grab and completely thrill you, you are not on the edge of your seat until the final balloon scene. But if it doesn't completely thrill you, it does thrill you. Its charms and amuses, not at a Princess Bride level, but something that at least understands what makes Princess Bride quite the film it is and tries to get there. And damn it gets close.
It looks stunning too.
So yeah why isn't this more lauded? Its as good as most the romantically remembered films of the time and I really wished I'd returned to it sooner as I suspect I'd have watched it many times.