On paper, Andy Helfer felt like a great fit for US Dredd. He was an Anglophile 2000AD fan, and his reboot of The Shadow title was highly regarded and had a Dredd-ish black humour tone.
In reality, though…
I knew him when he was an editor at DC, and remember trying to look politely non-appalled as -over a meal at DC’s expense - he told me his planned story arc for his Dredd book.