Forum’s Favourite Thrill - Young Middenface vs Zaucer of Zilk - Round 1 Heat 11

[NapalmKev]

Zaucer of Zilk.

Cheers

[The Enigmatic Dr X]

Middenface

[redsquirrel]

Zaucer of Zilk

The 2nd series did not quite capture the excellence of the first but was still vert good. Young Middenface was perfectly good but nothing out of the ordinary.

[paddykafka]

Zaucer of Zilk

[Rogue Judge]

Middenface. I'll take a chance on voting for anything SD related. Zaucer was a little strange for me.

[Colin YNWA]

From a quick glance through the thread this one seems close and so any last minute votes today could swing the result when I count up in the morning and annouce the final result, so if you haven't voted yet get um in...

[BPP]

Zilk

[I, Cosh]

Zaucer of Zilk. The first story was wonderful stuff. Marvellous McCarthy art with a suitably breezy story tying it all together. The disappointing second story showed that daftness isn't as easy as it looks.

Young Middenface. I've only read a couple of stories but I would've liked to see more. Am I right in saying it reflects Scottish politics in much the same way that Billy the Fish reflects the fortunes of Newcastle United FC?

Zaucer of Zilk. Just

[maryanddavid]

Zilk get the vote,  IIRC Young Middenface was a decent read but overstayed its welcome.

[Colin YNWA]

VOTING CLOSED

Well this is what we get when we get two great thrills. Most popular vote to date and going into the last day there was only one vote between the two stories. The last day however saw

Zaucer of Zilk

Confidently stride in those fancy pants into the 2nd Round. Nothing against Young Middenface but that's a relief as its a great thrill.