Forum’s Fav Thrill - The Out vs. The Order Rd 3 Heat 34

[Funt Solo]

The Order is just too confusing for me to enjoy. I liked the first series - everything else has unfortunately been a disappointment (even if well depicted, I'm sure cunningly wrought and with its heart in the right place).

I love The Out.

[Magnetica]

What Funt said.

The Out.

[moly]

The out

[NapalmKev]

The Out.

I'm a fan of The Order but The Out is just pure Gold!

Cheers

[Southstreeter]

Gruddammit I love both. Because The Out is going to win, my vote goes to The Order.

[Proudhuff]

The out

[Rogue Judge]

The Out.

Although Burns perfect artwork is almost enough to swing my vote.

[BPP]

the out instant classic vs impenetrable mess from bk 2

[Proudhuff]

Harsh but fair.

[norton canes]

The first two books of The Order versus the first two books of The Out would have been very close. But have others have said, The Order is losing a bit of steam(punk), so... The Out

[Colin YNWA]

With a day to got the result here is pretty clear, though I'm chuffed to see The Order doing better than I thought, it is a wonderful thrill. Tomorrow we'll have a result here so vote today.

[The Enigmatic Dr X]

The Out

[sintec]

Two thrills with stunning art that really suits the stories they're telling. I found The Order read much better collected than it did in the weekly in the Prog but even then it's huge cast and convoluted plotting makes it hard to keep track of what's going on. On the flips side I'm not sure The Out really knows where it's going but I'm not sure that really matters when it's such an enjoyable ride.

The Out

[IndigoPrime]

I'm not sure The Out really knows where it's going but I'm not sure that really matters when it's such an enjoyable ride.

I dunno. I get the feeling from interviews that Abnett has plotted an arc, but he's influenced heavily by the artist when it comes to where the journey goes between those points. I do like its sense of freedom immensely, and never quite knowing what's going to happen, yet it all remaining coherent. (By contrast, The Order has that sense of not knowing what's next, but unlike The Out—or, say Red Seas—it just doesn't hang together anymore.)

[Trooper McFad]

The Out