So I have just finished watching the original cast Star Trek films (this does not, in my book and for the purposes of this thread, include Generations). I was intending on starting this thread up whilst I was watching the first Star Trek film. Apparently it may be a little controversial.
My take on these films is that they are, altogether, above average sci-fi fare. They don't reach the lofty reaches of high-concept science fiction but they don't sink to the deep depths of lowest common denominator, action nonsense. They have consistently coherent plots where one scene flows well to the next. The acting (from the main cast, at least) is pretty hammy, but that is easy to forgive as the characters are iconic enough to carry the performances. I think that the quality between the films doesn't vary in large degrees which makes naming a preference or listing an order of preference somewhat difficult.
I went into watching these films with some cursory knowledge of some of the content. I am not sure whether I had ever seen one before in its entirety before these recent viewings, but if I had it was a long, long time ago and I don't remember it.
I would have liked to have gone with a surprise choice, nothing obvious, but I find myself unable to deny that Wrath of Khan is the best of the bunch. The self contained story doesn't over reach itself - even with the inclusion of the Genesis device which is OK as far as McGuffins go. There was a notable increase in quality in the production (which does noticeably dip in later films until Undiscovered Country) compared to previous film.
This film does narrowly beat Search for Spock for my top spot. I don't think Search for Spock stands as well by itself compared to Wrath of Khan, but it is certainly a worthy sequel of almost equal quality. Another downside is a personal preference of mine. Although I think Search for Spock handled it well, I am not a fan of the 'revived from death' trope.
I have a soft spot for the first film for what it tried to do. I think, on reflection, it's very different from the rest of the films. It felt like the closest to what the spirit of Star Trek strikes me as. The pacing may have been a bit clunky in places and perhaps the production was a case of 'eyes to big for the stomach'. There was more focus on exploration and investigation. They came across as resolving their problems by thinking them through rather than just firing phasers and punching things. That is an admirable quality for a film to have in my book.
So what is your favourite?
Talking Space Junk? Ear-munching worms? GrowGain Vulcans? Time-travelling whales? Floating heads shooting lasers out of its eyes? Or Purple Blooded Klingons?