SPOILERS: who’s back in 2000 AD Prog 2175?

[IndigoPrime]

SPOILERS: who's back in 2000 AD Prog 2175?


Death is the longest walk – but for Judge Barbara Hershey, it's only the first step!

HERSHEY: DISEASE by Rob Williams (Suicide Squad, Unfollow) and Simon Fraser (Nikolai Dante, Kingsman) begins in 2000 AD Prog 2175 and sees Judge Dredd's long-time ally using the cover of her faked funeral to head out into the world and right the wrongs committed by Judge Smiley!

Readers were saddened last year when a microbial virus first forced Hershey to resign her position as Chief Judge of Mega-City One and then apparently took her life in John Wagner and Colin MacNeil's Guatemala (2000 AD Progs 2150-2157). But all was not as it seemed – Judge Hershey was alive all along and she's now on a mission of revenge that will take her far beyond the walls of Mega-City One!

Williams and Fraser have crafted a tense, moving new series that gives one of the Dredd world's longest-standing characters a brand new lease of life – or is it merely borrowed time?

2000 AD Prog 2175 is out on 1 April 2020 and is available in print from some newsagents and comic book stores, as well as digitally from 2000 AD's webshop and apps.


The cover to 2000 AD Prog 2176 by Simon Fraser – out on 8 April
Created by John Wagner and Brian Bolland in 1980, Judge Barbara Hershey was one of Justice Department's most respected and capable young officers before she became Chief Judge. But it was during the critically-acclaimed The Small House storyline (2000 AD Progs 2100-2109) that her bond with long-time colleague Judge Dredd was near fatally damaged, following the revelation that there was a vast clandestine operation at the heart of Justice Department run by Judge Smiley, a Machiavellian manipulator who had controlled world events for decades. During last year's Guatemala storyline, and after Hershey's apparent death, the new Chief Judge was seen talking to an anonymous voice by radio – the identity of that voice remained unknown ... until now!


The scene from John Wagner and Colin MacNeil's Guatemala in 2000 AD Prog 2151
Editor of 2000 AD, Matt Smith, said: "When Hershey stood down as Chief Judge, Rob came to me with the idea of a solo series, with her repairing Smiley's legacy in the wake of The Small House storyline. John said he had no plans for Hershey, and was happy for us to use her as we saw fit. When John wrote the first episode of Guatemala, he came up with a cover story that would take Hershey out of the game, with no one but Logan, Dredd and a select few others knowing the truth – and Rob worked his scripts in tandem with that. Hershey is still dying – she's taking medication to stave off whatever microbe she's been infected with – but she's going out with the intention of righting wrongs that were done on her watch. Rob and Si's series is a redemptive, violent, propulsive new arc for Hershey, with lots more surprises still in store."

Co-creator of Judge Hershey, John Wagner, said: "When discussing the new series with Matt Smith and how it might fit in with Guatemala, I suggested Hershey's death could just be a subterfuge – I had no plans for Hershey and am happy to see others take her in new directions, so there's a little clue in Guatemala, that I don't think anyone spotted, that things were not as they seemed! And who doesn't love a good old story of revenge?"


Rob Williams said: "The idea for the series came off the back of The Small House. I felt the "I no longer recognise your authority" line had been building for years, and was organic and justified, but it also didn't really let Hershey tell her side of things. I felt we'd undersold her a bit. And even in the scene that followed it that John wrote, when Hershey and Dredd meet on their bikes – that we play on in Hershey episode one – that was still written from Dredd's point of view. I felt, after how long she'd been in the strip, she deserved a version that told her side of the story. A Long Walk for someone who's deserved a journey that isn't just going into The Cursed Earth. A Long Walk for someone burnt out and dying, who is asking herself the question – my life's run its purpose. So, what's left? Can she find that?

"Simon and I have worked together a bunch of times and he's a good friend. I thought he'd be great for this. He said he wanted to draw her looking her age. Which was tonally exactly the themes of the story needed.

"John agreeing we could tell this story, and to fit it in around Hershey's 'death' in his story was important. Ultimately, she's his character. Boorman's Point Blank was one of the big inspirations behind this series. A revenge thriller, with Hershey as this unstoppable, grim force. There's a school of reading Point Blank as how Lee Marvin's character dies in the opening scene, and everything that follows is his fantasy just before he dies. Maybe this is Hershey's fantasy just as she dies. Or maybe not..."


Simon Fraser said: "The planning process was, and I'm paraphrasing, "Hey Si , you want to do a hard as nails revenge thriller, kind of like Point Blank , but with Judge Hershey?" My reply, also paraphrasing, was " Yes!" or maybe "**** Yes!", which is my usual response when Rob suggests things.

"I was looking for a story to stretch my new digital drawing tools. Lots of world building , which I love, but not much dialog ... which I also love. I'm also very happy to be drawing a lady of advancing years being very angry and violent.

"Hershey has been the good and dutiful public servant for a long time, she's taken a lot of crap, stoically and responsibly, now let's see how she chooses to close her account! I know that people get upset because we're bringing a character 'back from the dead', but I think we're giving an amazing woman the ending she deserves."

[Richard]

Thanks for posting this Indigo. Or Mr Prime, if you prefer.

I still think this detracts from the emotional impact of Hershey's death scene in Guatemala, but hopefully this story will turn out to be so good that I stop minding that and it all seems worth it after all. I'm still sceptical though. Bringing people back from the dead is usually a mistake. I want to be proved wrong.

I don't want to be relentlessly negative though, so I'll end on a positive note: it's good to see Simon Fraser back in the prog, I love his innovative use of colour in this series, and I like that he is depicting Hershey at her true age, instead of making her look about 20 as so often happens.

[Greg M.]

I think the Hershey story, whilst obviously technically competent and blessed with superb art, is a bad idea. To me, it has the same impact on 'Guatemala' as the Chopper sequels have on 'Song of the Surfer'. The idea of continuing to immerse characters from the Dreddverse in this Smiley retcon malarkey – for my money, the worst thing that ever happened to the series – does not appeal, irrespective of whether John Wagner approved it. Williams says "I think we're giving an amazing woman the ending she deserves." She had the ending she deserved. Her creator wrote it (modified, it appears, to accommodate this story.) With all due respect to Williams, whatever roaring rampage of revenge he writes, he's unlikely to better that. Some of you will, of course, want to give him the benefit of the doubt on that score.

[TordelBack]

This currently makes no sense to me. If Hershey was well enough to be off doing the her anti-Smiley Absalomish bucket list, why couldn't she have been involved in rescuing her own family in Guatemala prior to faking her death? She wasn't even Chief Cheez at that point.

And more significantly why couldn't this story take place between her resignation and her death? Williams could have made all his points about Hershey in the process, and retained the poignancy of her death.

I'm still going to give it a chance, but it needs to be very very good to avoid the Curse of Chopper.

[paddykafka]

I'm holding onto a thin hope that one of my favourite Dredd supporting cast members, Dirty Frank, will somehow make a return as well. Considering that his reported "Death" happened off-screen, it might not be beyond the bounds of possibility. Just so long as it does not involve him being pictured stepping out of the shower in a Dallas type of It-Was-All-Actually-A-Dream scenario. Because that would be just, well, a little too much to handle...

[Professor Bear]

LOL you absolute suckers.