I have been harsh on "Nu" Trek, but this show is giving me hope. Not just hope for the franchise, but that general hope for the future that Picarse and STD have utterly failed to deliver.
I still have a few nit-picks, this is the way. (spoilers up to episode 4)
Uhuru's orphan back story was just lazy clichéThe security officer is basically called Gandalf Hitler. Good character despite that.
Nurse Chapel should wear her hair in a beehive at least once so I can complain about leaning too heavily on nostalgia
The science is kinda goofy, but in that charming way that TOS did science. I have always said that Star Trek inspired my interest in science that let me understand how shonky Trek science is.
Gregory Peck's grandson does an OK Spock, but he just doesn't have Nimoy's charisma. Then again, who does?
I'll tell you who, Captain goddamn Pike. Swoon. His hair is nearly as good as mine.
I also have a soft spot for the blind engineer. He's that no nonsense professional archetype like Odo.
Number One is #1.
Overall, I'd say it's off to a stronger start than TNG or DS9.