Main Menu
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - Rogue Judge

#1291
General / Re: Judge Dredd Graphic Novels - Question!
04 August, 2016, 06:18:44 PM
Quote from: Butch on 04 August, 2016, 01:35:11 PM

Douglas Wolk's superb Dredd Reckoning blog includes an exhaustive and up to date reading guide to the collected Dredd (including Hachette works, where appropriate). Though less visually dazzling than Jimbo's reading trees, it really does include everything:

http://dreddreviews.blogspot.co.uk/2013/02/housekeeping-3-index-and-guide.html


Thanks Butch, this is extremely complete and will help guide me for sure - thank you! Interestingly, I noticed Wolk is also the Writer of Dredd: Mega City Two from IDW. I collected the IDW Dredd run but it is not very good - it is lacking everything that makes 2000AD Dredd great.


Quote from: Molch-R on 04 August, 2016, 11:28:04 AM
In terms of recommendations, rather than reading order, Robo-K33f and I did this video guide a while back: https://youtu.be/1yUwX1rR-zc

Molch-R, thanks so much for your video link - it was great! (I gave it a thumbs up) Definatly motivates me to keep collecting & reading.


Quote from: IndigoPrime on 04 August, 2016, 10:48:43 AM
Ah, good old Google. I'm not sure if this is the best of Dark Jimbo's images (it's a bit small), but it at least gives you a timeline of what to read and when:

https://forums.2000adonline.com/index.php?topic=43316.0

Rogue Judge: depending on how much of a completist you want to be, the Case Files aren't the entire story. The Restricted Files give you strips printed outside 2000 AD and the Magazine, in specials and annuals. The second and third volumes in particular are superb. Judge Anderson somewhat interlinks with Dredd, although less so as the series goes on. Dead Man, as already noted, adds plenty of context and backstory to Necropolis (although it's arguably inessential). America was inexplicably omitted from the Case Files (I don't care what anyone argues to the contrary — it was originally a Dredd strip in the Meg) and is required reading when you get to that point in the Dredd run (around CF 15).

All the rest are pretty much asides. You'll lose nothing if you don't read Batman/Dredd (and, frankly, they're not that great anyway, to my jaded eyes), Chopper is frequently great but links only relatively slightly with Dredd post-Oz. The Death stuff I can take or leave. Taxidermist is really fun but again inessential. Kenny Who? is one of my favourite Dredd collections of all time (Cam Kennedy greatness!), but much of it's in the Case Files elsewhere.

Thanks a lot IndigoPrime, I appreciate all your info! That chart is amazing, I will definitely use it going forward. Im usually quite a completionist so will get quite a lot of these recommendations. Mostly Case/Restricted Files, Anderson, and Deadman. I purchased and thoroughly enjoyed America, it was such a well written story.


Quote from: AlexF on 04 August, 2016, 09:03:35 AM
I get the weekly Progs + monthly Megs, and buy the Case Files as they come out. Not that I always find time to read them...
I occasionally buy trades of the newer Dredd epics, but only if I really liked them (e.g. I did buy Titan, but didn't buy Dark Justice. That one was good, but no so good that I don't mind waiting a decade to get it in the Case Files. I can always read the Progs again!)

Good to know AlexF, I think I might start by collecting all the Case Files and will give the Meg a try as well and being selective with my current epics like you suggested. Think Ill start with Day of Chaos.
#1292
General / Re: Judge Dredd Graphic Novels - Question!
04 August, 2016, 06:16:17 AM
Quote from: PsychoGoatee on 02 August, 2016, 08:32:23 AM
Kudos on hopping onto the Dredd train! Agreed it's the best thing going!

A note just in case, if you want you can get more Case Files early, since they're up to 27 now in the UK. You can also order them from sellers on Amazon.com (USA), I figure that's probably true on amazon.ca too. Case Files 14 is the Necropolis epic for example, would recommend checking that out ASAP.

Speaking of Necropolis, you need The Dead Man! It's available in a collection called "Tales of the Dead Man", without Judge Dredd in the book title. It's an important story that isn't included in the Case Files. Well, "The Dead Man" solo series isn't in the case files, a Dredd story follow-up called "Tale of the Dead Man" is in Case Files 14.

And you definitely don't want to skip Trifecta. Though it would be enhanced if you check out the Low-Life and Simping Detective series as well.

Day of Chaos - Fallout is another one for the list there.

Dark Justice is another very must read one.


Thanks so much for your suggestions gents! PsychoGoatee, I took your advice and decided to go forward with the UK Case files. The American volumes come out way to slowly and are so far behind that I will collect the UK volumes going forward (not to mention the cover art for the UK volumes is far superior). The art in Dark Justice looks incredble, I will also order that right away! Thanks again, Im quite excited to read 30 years worth of Dredd!

Do most people here collect the current trades as they come out, or just read the progs and wait for the Case Files?

Thanks WhizzBang too, I will google your recommendations! 
#1293
General / Judge Dredd Graphic Novels - Question!
02 August, 2016, 07:10:22 AM
Hello, I'm relatively new to Dredd, having only collected and read the first 10 Case Files, Origins and America so far. Dredd is simply the best, so I'm diving in with both feet and plan to collect each new current Dredd paperback that comes out (starting as far back as Judge Dredd Day of Chaos and up to the most current story).

My question: Is there a list of Judge Dredd Graphic Novel reading orders? What has been released, what order to read them, and what is coming out soon?

I live in Canada, and looking on Amazon.ca I can see that I need the following books (in order):

-Judge Dredd Day of Chaos: Fourth Faction
-Judge Dredd Day of Chaos: Endgame
-Judge Dredd: Trifecta (This appears to be a crossover, is it necessary?)
-Judge Dredd: Dead Zone
-Judge Dredd: Titan

Is this a solid list or am I missing anything you would recommend? Thank you so much for any of your answers!
#1294
Welcome to the board / Re: Welcome to 2000AD Online
01 August, 2016, 08:56:25 PM
Quick question - Im just new and I can't find a place to access my profile. I would like to add a avatar picture & some info if I can. Thank you!
#1295
Welcome to the board / Hi - New 2000AD Reader
01 August, 2016, 08:07:11 PM
Hello, I am new to 2000AD, from Canada. The new (2012) Derdd movie got me into Judge Dredd several months ago, and I cant believe what I have been missing! In the last few months I have purchased and read the first 10 volumes of the Complete Case Files and America, a few volumes of Rogue Trooper Tales of Nu Earth, and the Zenith series (and all the free downloads from the 2000AD app). The humor/satire/violence of Dredd makes it my favorite book of them all right now.

I have been reading comics (mostly Marvel) for 20ish years but had never tried any European comics. I really appreciate the format and am not afraid to admit that European comics, specifically 2000AD, are much better than most American books (way better written - smart and unpredictable stories not concerned about PC).

I plan to buy recent Dredd graphic novels and Jaegir next. I look forward to asking a bunch of questions and reading up on all the things I have been missing. Thanks.