People change. The world changes too. One of the interesting things about going through the UC is that I liked certain strips less than I thought I would (including, surprisingly, some classic Strontium Dog), found some strips borderline unreadable (sorry, Rabo-Hunter fans), but broadly enjoyed the more recent fare, often beyond what I was expecting (including ‘reboot’ Stront).
From a purely objective standpoint, however, it’s hard to argue against Smith’s tenure. That 2000 AD still exists at all is quite something, given the market. But that he’s managed to keep things fresh and interesting across two decades as Tharg (and also taking on the Meg at the same time) is a great indication of his abilities.