Was the helmet too big or urbans' chin too small? A couple of the other judges had chins more in proportion to the helmet. As different artists give us different views of Dredds' world so the two films give us different approaches. I like them both but for me if you could blend the two films I would like it better. Again personally, the best Dredd film ever made was Bladerunner, atmospheric, futuristic yet gritty and real. I've been with it since Prog 1 and still look forward every week to it dropping on the mat... How old!!!