Just taking inspiration from another thread: There's some crazy stuff that Alan Grant writes that just doesn't seem to fit in with Dredd contintuity. What's the crack - pretend they haven't happened or just assume they were dealt with behind the scenes?
The worst thing was the Chief Judge and Dredd deciding to nuke most of MC1's young children on their crusade to the Cursed Earth, in Anderson. For my money, it's hard to drop something like that into a long-established continuity without preparing for years of reprecussions, but there was no mention of it ever again. I really find it hard to accept it as fitting into Dredd's backstory.
For my money, I believe Alan Grant was a fine Dredd writer when teamed up with John Wagner, but I'm not sure if he 'gets' Dredd or the Judge system any more. Hard and dictatorial bastards they may be but you don't kill all your own nation's children then sit back and move onto other things.
Also, Grant often show Dredd recommending death sentences and torture, both of which have been shown to only be used in extreme circumstances - the Security of the City Act seems to be the only time the judges will resort to these methods. also, Wagner's Dredd seems a lot more intelligent and well-spoken than Grant's.
The worst thing was the Chief Judge and Dredd deciding to nuke most of MC1's young children on their crusade to the Cursed Earth, in Anderson. For my money, it's hard to drop something like that into a long-established continuity without preparing for years of reprecussions, but there was no mention of it ever again. I really find it hard to accept it as fitting into Dredd's backstory.
For my money, I believe Alan Grant was a fine Dredd writer when teamed up with John Wagner, but I'm not sure if he 'gets' Dredd or the Judge system any more. Hard and dictatorial bastards they may be but you don't kill all your own nation's children then sit back and move onto other things.
Also, Grant often show Dredd recommending death sentences and torture, both of which have been shown to only be used in extreme circumstances - the Security of the City Act seems to be the only time the judges will resort to these methods. also, Wagner's Dredd seems a lot more intelligent and well-spoken than Grant's.
