Dave may be a lovely bloke, but if someone made a film of something I'd had a hand in creating, I dare say I may not be an entirely reliable source of objective criticism - Alan Moore's vitriol is just as good an example of this as Dave Gibbons' enthusiasm.
Personally (and this is not to say that many won't enjoy the end result), I think the main problem with the film is that at no point has anything seen thus far led me to believe that irony is part of the package - exactly the opposite if the rubber costumes, slow-mo fights and action figure spin-offs are anything to go by , irony arguably being a necessary componant of any iconoclastic or deconstructionist work.
I still remember laughing at the 'Rob Liefeld's Watchmen 2' comic cover mock-up, because, like everyone else laughing at it, I believed that no-one could possibly possess such a lack of self-awareness.
Lesson learned, I suppose.
Personally (and this is not to say that many won't enjoy the end result), I think the main problem with the film is that at no point has anything seen thus far led me to believe that irony is part of the package - exactly the opposite if the rubber costumes, slow-mo fights and action figure spin-offs are anything to go by , irony arguably being a necessary componant of any iconoclastic or deconstructionist work.
I still remember laughing at the 'Rob Liefeld's Watchmen 2' comic cover mock-up, because, like everyone else laughing at it, I believed that no-one could possibly possess such a lack of self-awareness.
Lesson learned, I suppose.
