I'd say that my limited exposure to Warhammer media paints a far more worrying and sustained fantasy world than steampunk does, and that Stross and his ilk are no different than goths moaning about how the popularity of the Twilight movies cheapens their original idea of listening to Sisters of Mercy albums in a frilly black dress while shouting at their mum to get dinner ready.
Leaving aside that reimagining the past as a fantasy world is essentially imaging how it could/should have been better rather than how great child labor was, if it's okay for the BBC to sweep the treatment of black people in a period setting under the carpet for cosy, critically-acclaimed adaptations of hormonal housewife lit-porn, then some people taking their own time and money to dress like cunts and play pretend about things that did not actually happen and are a fantasy doesn't bother me at all in the same way that seeing children play at being princesses or pirates doesn't because the former aren't going to grow up to die in a Parisian underpass and the latter aren't going to grow up to rape their way across the Caribbean and then die of skurvy.
As for the 'class' angle to it all, the whole point of cosplay is to produce elaborate costumes and preen like a peacock, and a cloth cap and string vest does not quite pass muster in that context in the same way huge goggles, ludicrous hats and deeply effeminate waistcoats do. Thus it follows that if you're going to pretend to be the kind of character who dresses like that, it makes sense that they would have to be a person of means and not a penniless oik.
Leaving aside that reimagining the past as a fantasy world is essentially imaging how it could/should have been better rather than how great child labor was, if it's okay for the BBC to sweep the treatment of black people in a period setting under the carpet for cosy, critically-acclaimed adaptations of hormonal housewife lit-porn, then some people taking their own time and money to dress like cunts and play pretend about things that did not actually happen and are a fantasy doesn't bother me at all in the same way that seeing children play at being princesses or pirates doesn't because the former aren't going to grow up to die in a Parisian underpass and the latter aren't going to grow up to rape their way across the Caribbean and then die of skurvy.
As for the 'class' angle to it all, the whole point of cosplay is to produce elaborate costumes and preen like a peacock, and a cloth cap and string vest does not quite pass muster in that context in the same way huge goggles, ludicrous hats and deeply effeminate waistcoats do. Thus it follows that if you're going to pretend to be the kind of character who dresses like that, it makes sense that they would have to be a person of means and not a penniless oik.
