It suits me perfectly, but I'm completely biased and perfection is an odd concept when it comes to a creative endevour: fairly hard to prove it.
It's perfect for me because it reminds me of the old Clint Eastwood actioners with a bit of Robocop and Madmax and Escape from New York, and it reminds me of these films, notsomuch because it's has some sort of contrived 'retro'-vibe to it, but because these films share something of the... um... 'balls-to-the-wall' nature of Dredd that I haven't seen in a long time from anywhere else. It also helps that it's also a faithful adaptation of my favourite character and I think it has a depth that can be easily overlooked upon first viewing. Anyway, yeah, for me; perfect.
It's perfect for me because it reminds me of the old Clint Eastwood actioners with a bit of Robocop and Madmax and Escape from New York, and it reminds me of these films, notsomuch because it's has some sort of contrived 'retro'-vibe to it, but because these films share something of the... um... 'balls-to-the-wall' nature of Dredd that I haven't seen in a long time from anywhere else. It also helps that it's also a faithful adaptation of my favourite character and I think it has a depth that can be easily overlooked upon first viewing. Anyway, yeah, for me; perfect.

