>>it would be cheap as well... send in your one page story for glory wages... i.e. nowt
This, or something similar, comes up every few years and usually ends up provoking a reaction from the Nerve Centre.
There was a debate about this a couple of years ago on one of the mailing lists, the idea proposed being that the Meg could run original material and not reprints and still save itself some money by using work from basically unpaid/very low-paid newbies who would just be happy to get the exposure and experience.
Andy Diggle's 100% correction reaction was as follows:
1. If your work's good enough to be published, it's good enough to be paid for.
2. They're there to entertain the readers, not exploit them.
3. They'd be deliberately running cheapo work which they knew to be sub-standard (after all, if it was truly up to scratch, they'd be willing to pay a proper going rate for it) while still expecting the readers to pay full price for the comic it was appearing in.
The one-page strip idea isn't a bad idea, but no way should anyone ever do work for a professional publisher for free. Everyone else in the comic is getting paid - why shouldn't you be.
Plus, if you show a professional publisher (or any employer, for that matter) that you're a mug willing to work for free or ultra-low wages when everyone else is getting the going rate, what compunction will they ever have to pay you any more?
- Gordon, Father of the Chapel
This, or something similar, comes up every few years and usually ends up provoking a reaction from the Nerve Centre.
There was a debate about this a couple of years ago on one of the mailing lists, the idea proposed being that the Meg could run original material and not reprints and still save itself some money by using work from basically unpaid/very low-paid newbies who would just be happy to get the exposure and experience.
Andy Diggle's 100% correction reaction was as follows:
1. If your work's good enough to be published, it's good enough to be paid for.
2. They're there to entertain the readers, not exploit them.
3. They'd be deliberately running cheapo work which they knew to be sub-standard (after all, if it was truly up to scratch, they'd be willing to pay a proper going rate for it) while still expecting the readers to pay full price for the comic it was appearing in.
The one-page strip idea isn't a bad idea, but no way should anyone ever do work for a professional publisher for free. Everyone else in the comic is getting paid - why shouldn't you be.
Plus, if you show a professional publisher (or any employer, for that matter) that you're a mug willing to work for free or ultra-low wages when everyone else is getting the going rate, what compunction will they ever have to pay you any more?
- Gordon, Father of the Chapel
