Forum’s Favourite Festive Front Tourney - 1992 vs 2015

[Colin YNWA]

Back for more are you Colin 'Two Covers' MacNeill. Well this time you face Ian 'Just look at those astonishing colours' Kennedy. He might have a silly wrestling name, but painting aeronautics is his game. Think you can handle it?

Vote by simply popping the year you think has the best cover in a reply to this thread. No messing about this round just 2 DAYS this round and I'll close up voting first thing Monday 14th December (if my timings are right?!?). Count up and the top cover will go through to the semi-finals.

Any questions just ask.

1992 - Prog 815 - Larger image

2015 - Prog 1961 - Larger image

What the HELL is all the nonsense? Find out more about it all

[rogue69]

1992

[Magnetica]

92

[Dark Jimbo]

Sorry, Ian - it's got to be 1992.

[broodblik]

1992

[TordelBack]

Love that Ian Kennedy Dredd, so colourful and classic.

But making the grumpiest Santa,  and imbuing his sack with such looming, menacing potential, that's a gift that only Colin MacNeil brings. Gotta be 1992.

[SmallBlueThing(Reborn)]

Has to be 1992, for it's Christmassy and the Kennedy one, though fair bursting with colour in comparison, is not.

And that's the thrust of the tourney.

SBT

[abelardsnazz]

Colin is great, but I'm going to break with the run here and give my vote to Ian's magnificent 2015 work.

[Rogue Judge]

Two top artists...MacNeil's is more of a true Christmas cover but, going by my own "which cover would I like to own most" decision criteria, I have to go with Ian's 2015 timeless cover.

[Funt Solo]

1992, please.

[DrJomster]

They're both good, but I do love the 1992 Coilin one a bit more. Dredd doesn't look happy, not at all...

[shaolin_monkey]

1992 is just more festive.

[Dandontdare]

92 - Nobody does "Dredd looking grumpy about Christmas" like Colin

[The Mind of Wolfie Smith]

2015. along with john m burns, kennedy is the most underrated of them all.

[Colin YNWA]

Bit weekend quiet this one.So if you are passing by feel free to get your vote in today and I'll count this one on the morning and kick off the semis Tuesday (I think it is)